In 'It Misses Its Friend: A Chilling Halloween Horror,' a candy mystery leads to a terrifying discovery. An uncanny haunting from the past, filled with chilling suspense & family secrets.

Listen for scary twists!

A pillowcase full of candy is a map of a successful night. But sometimes, a stranger leaves an unmarked offering—not a treat, but a message, delivered to a door it has been waiting for. In this truly eerie episode of 'Why Me?', titled 'It Misses Its Friend: A Chilling Halloween Horror,' young Leo, a proud skeptic, finds a peculiar piece of saltwater taffy. Tucked inside its plain wrapper is a cryptic fortune: 'Look under the loose board. It misses its friend.' Dismissing it as a mere prank, Leo is unprepared for the slow, creeping dread that begins to permeate his world, turning the familiar sounds of his old house into unsettling whispers. This Halloween tale is a classic example of when the ordinary twists into the uncanny.

This psychological horror story delves into the subtle ways fear can burrow into the mind, transforming ordinary sounds into harbingers of the unexplained. Leo, convinced it's just his imagination, battles an irrational feeling of being watched, his skepticism slowly crumbling under the weight of an unseen presence. The narrative masterfully builds supernatural suspense, making every creak and gurgle of the old house a source of mounting anxiety. His search for the 'loose board' culminates in a moment of pure, chilling discovery: a glass eye, from an old porcelain doll, staring up with a vacant, timeless gaze. Relief washes over him, thinking it's just a silly prank. Oh, how wrong he is.

The true horrifying discovery unravels when Leo shares his find with his mother. Her reaction shatters his world, revealing a long-buried family tragedy: a lost twin brother, Nathan, who vanished from their very house decades ago. The glass eye, from Nathan’s beloved doll, becomes a macabre key, unlocking a past that refuses to stay buried. This twisted tale delivers a scary ending that embodies the cruel irony often found in Tales from the Crypt, combined with the profound, unsettling questions of The Twilight Zone. The message, 'It misses its friend,' takes on a terrifying new meaning, revealing Leo's horrifying role as the unwitting messenger in a timeless, familial haunting.

Join The Shadow Teller for an uncanny story where innocence meets insidious supernatural forces, and a childhood curiosity opens a door to unfathomable grief. This episode is a must-listen for fans of creeping horror, paranormal narratives, and macabre thrillers that explore the lasting scars of loss and the relentless patience of the supernatural. 'It Misses Its Friend' is a suspenseful tale designed to linger, compelling you to question the quiet corners of your own home.

'Why Me?' brings uncanny stories and psychological horror tales that resonate across generations of thoughtful horror fans. Prepare for chilling narratives, atmospheric sound design, and stories that will haunt your thoughts. We craft each narrative to build pervasive unease, ensuring suspense from the first minute. Step into the shadows with The Shadow Teller, where every story leaves you asking... 'Why Me?'